Content Literacy and Affective Learning
How important
is the affective domain really in education? Do students genuinely need to be
excited in class? Does it really matter, academically, if they believe in themselves?
Or is it enough to simply be told what needs to be done and how to get there? The
focus of national standards and every educational reform focuses on the
cognitive domain, although research has shown that the affective variables are
critical in students’ learning.
Richardson, Morgan, and Fleener
(2012, p. 30) reference a study by Van
Halkenburg and Holden to demonstrate exactly how important the affective domain
is. This student indicates that it is a
1 to 1 relationship and that, “every cognitive approach is concerned as much
with affection as cognition (p. 30).” Attitude, motivation, and conation are
the three most important affective factors in student learning. The students
first must want to learn. He or she needs to feel like the classroom is
welcoming and accepting, while offering learning opportunities that are
enjoyable and rewarding. Finally, the student needs to have a sense of
determination to learn. This is more than simply wanting to learn, but putting
forth the effort and not giving up until a goal has been achieved. All of these
things can be addressed and fostered by the teacher. Study guides, reading selection,
and homework assignments can all be designed with these factors in mind.
The affective
domain plays directly into content literacy instruction. A focus on content
literacy, while important for student learning, is also a way to motivate
students. With this type of instruction, students are building skills in reading,
writing, and communication without realizing it, because they are doing it within the context of other subjects. Students get frustrated when they are reading
or writing for the sake of reading or writing. Vocabulary, comprehension, study
strategies and writing are all referred to by Misilus (2009) as tools for
developing literacy skills. Teacher can develop instruction around these tools
in order to mold students into independent learners. Content literacy drives
students toward critical thinking and a more thorough understanding of content.
My
concern is for the underachieving student. How do you motivate the consistent
low performers to do well? Content literacy is important because of the way our
neural pathways work. Content literacy helps to build literacy skills in all different
subjects. If, however, the student does not have the basic literacy skills to
even maintain average grades in English, they will be held back across all
content areas. How do you foster a positive attitude in a child who is
struggling in language arts and, as a result, struggles through every subject because
reading and writing has become a focus in all content areas.
Nancy,
ReplyDeleteI often wonder how strategies like this will apply to those struggling students, or those who aren't motivated to learn at all. "Students first must want to learn." I absolutely agree, but I have come across many who just have no desire and just disrupt the class as much as they can. This is my biggest concern if and when I become a classroom teacher- how to approach and motivate these students. I have seen that part of the problem is just the dry, boring material they sometimes have to read. We can't always make everything shiny and tailor made to each student, but sometimes I think I couldn't get through it without falling asleep either.
Maybe these students are the ones who need the affective domain the most- they need to see how reading applies to their everyday lives. Whether through functional text (finding their favorite restaurant menu) or developing a project that requires their creativity in something where they excel, tapping into that spark is the most important thing. If they can apply what they are learning to their world, it is more likely to stick. I think that is the biggest challenge facing teachers in a world that is now geared toward tests.
Great post Nancy- thanks!
Nancy, you said it best by saying, "students get frustrated when they are reading or writing for the sake of reading or writing." It helps motivate a student when they are reading or writing for a purpose. I agree with Robin when she says we should show these unmotivated students how reading applies to their everyday life. As teachers, if we can find a way to do this, then reading and writing won't just be for the sake of reading and writing. I think that when a student is struggling in language arts, teachers need to recognize this and do something about it even if they are teaching the other subjects. Great insight, Nancy!
ReplyDeleteAll good points. Nancy, sometimes we have to dig (i.e., Build relationships with the student and his/her family and use those connections.) to find out why students are being disruptive or appear to lack desire. (Are they masking poor skills? Are basic needs (e.g., food and shelter) going unmet?)
ReplyDelete